MGM v. Scheider

From wikilawschool.net. Wiki Law School does not provide legal advice. For educational purposes only.
MGM v. Scheider
Court New York Court of Appeals
Citation 360 N.E.2d 930
Date decided December 28, 1976

Facts

  • Roy Scheider (1932-2008) = star of the Jaws movies, famous actor = defendant
  • Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, Inc. = MGM = major movie studio = plaintiff
  • The 2 parties signed a contract to complete a pilot movie & a related television series.
  • Not all the details were spelled out in the contract. For example, MGM hadn't provided a starting date for the TV series.

Procedural History

  • MGM sued Scheider in New York Supreme Court (trial court) for not completing a movie series.
  • The trial court found that a contract existed between MGM & Scheider.
  • MGM won in the trial court & Appellate Division.

Issues

Where parties have

  • agreed to the essential terms of a contract &
  • begun performance of a contract in good faith,
does an enforceable contract exist?

Holding

Yes. If parties have agreed to the essential terms & begun performance, & an objective method for deciding remaining terms exists, the contract is valid & enforceable.

Judgment

Affirmed

Resources