1st Hawaiian Bank v. Zukerkorn

From wikilawschool.net. Wiki Law School does not provide legal advice. For educational purposes only.
Revision as of 20:17, October 20, 2023 by DeRien (talk | contribs)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

1st Hawaiian Bank v. Zukerkorn
Court Hawaii Court of Appeals
Citation 633 P.2d 550
Date decided September 4, 1981

Facts

  • "Zukerkorn" = Mr. Zukerkorn = defendant = borrower of money
  • First Hawaiian Bank = plaintiff = "Bank"
  • In 1965, Zukerkorn executed a $6,000 demand note with the Bank
  • In 1966, Zukerkorn executed a $2,500 2-year note with the Bank
  • Zukerkorn didn't pay anything on these aforesaid bank notes
  • In 1973, Zukerkorn was approved on a car loan.
  • In 1975, when Zukerkorn applied for a credit card, his application was initially declined, & he was reminded about his un-paid debts. In exchange for agreeing to pay $100/month on his "old" debts, his credit card application was approved.
  • In 1976, Zukerkorn made several payment for $100/month to the Bank.

Procedural History

In 1978, the Bank sued Zukerkorn on the 1965 & 1966 debts + the credit card balance.

The Bank won a summary judgment in the trial court in Hawaii.

Issues

Does a debtor's new promise [the 1975 credit card application] to pay a debt trigger a new limitations period for stale debts that would otherwise be un-collectable because of the statute of limitations?

Arguments

Zukerkorn argued that the bank's collection activity came too late.

  • Zukerkorn argued that there was a 6-year statute of limitation on collecting a debt in Hawaii.

Holding

Yes. A debtor's new promise to pay a debt triggers a new limitations period for stale debts that would otherwise be un-collectable because of the statute of limitations.

Case is remanded.

Judgment

Reversed the trial court as to the 1965 & 1966 debts while affirming the credit card balance

Reasons

Judge Burns: A debtor's new promise to pay a debt begins a new limitations period for old debts, even if the applicable statute of limitations has already run.

Rule

Upon the expiration of the statute of limitations on a debt, the lender can no longer collect. However, certain action by the debtor can re-start the clock.

Resources