Newman v. Bost: Difference between revisions
From wikilawschool.net. Wiki Law School does not provide legal advice. For educational purposes only.
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
|issues=By handing over a set of keys, can a person effectively deliver a gift of all personal property located in the person's home? | |issues=By handing over a set of keys, can a person effectively deliver a gift of all personal property located in the person's home? | ||
|holding=No; by handing over a set of keys only constructively delivers gifts that aren't present in the home or are incapable of physical delivery. | |holding=No; by handing over a set of keys only constructively delivers gifts that aren't present in the home or are incapable of physical delivery. | ||
|judgment=Reversed | |||
|reasons=Justice Furches: Most items in the house weren't gifted to Newman by constructive delivery when Van Pelt handed her the keys to the home | |reasons=Justice Furches: Most items in the house weren't gifted to Newman by constructive delivery when Van Pelt handed her the keys to the home | ||
|rule=''Donatio [https://www.quimbee.com/keyterms/gifts-causa-mortis Causa Mortis]'' | |rule=''Donatio [https://www.quimbee.com/keyterms/gifts-causa-mortis Causa Mortis]'' | ||
Latest revision as of 13:19, April 11, 2024
| Newman v. Bost | |
| Court | North Carolina Supreme Court |
|---|---|
| Citation | 29 S.E. 848, 122 N.C. 524 |
| Date decided | April 1, 1898 |
Facts
- Mr. Van Pelt = an outright house owner; a wealthy man in North Carolina in the late 1800s whose wife was deceased; he didn't have any children
- Mrs. Newman = the housekeeper of Mr. Pelt
- Pelt gave Newman a set of keys & announced his desire to bequeath everything in his house to her
- 1 of the keys was to a bureau in his house which contained a $3,000 life insurance policy
- In 1896, Van Pelt died intestate & without children in Statesville, North Carolina
- Upon Van Pelt's death, a relative of Van Pelt named Mr. Bost emerged claiming to be the administer of Van Pelt's house & other possessions
- Bost cashed in on all the belongings in the house
Procedural History
- Newman sued Bost in the Superior Court in North Carolina
- Newman won in the trial court
Issues
By handing over a set of keys, can a person effectively deliver a gift of all personal property located in the person's home?
Holding
No; by handing over a set of keys only constructively delivers gifts that aren't present in the home or are incapable of physical delivery.
Judgment
Reversed
Reasons
Justice Furches: Most items in the house weren't gifted to Newman by constructive delivery when Van Pelt handed her the keys to the home
Rule
Donatio Causa Mortis
Resources
