Lucy v. Zehmer: Difference between revisions
From wikilawschool.net. Wiki Law School does not provide legal advice. For educational purposes only.
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Infobox Case Brief | {{Infobox Case Brief | ||
|court=Supreme Court | |court=Virginia Supreme Court | ||
|citation=196 Va. 493 (1954) | |citation=196 Va. 493 (1954) | ||
|date=1954 | |date=November 22, 1954 | ||
|subject=Contracts | |subject=Contracts | ||
|case_treatment=No | |||
|facts=Zehmer owned a large farm in Virginia that Lucy wanted to buy, and he had tried to buy for several years. | |||
One night when Zehmer was drunk, Lucy and he were arguing about if Lucy could afford to buy the farm for $50,000. Lucy said, "I bet you wouldn't take $50,000 for that place." Zehmer responded, "Yes I would too; you wouldn't give fifty." An agreement was made and written up on the spot that the farm would be sold to Lucy for $50,000. Zehmer and his wife signed it along with Lucy. | |||
|issues=Is the agreement an enforceable contract, even if one party did not really mean to make an agreement? | |||
|arguments=Zehmer said he was too drunk to make an agreement. He didn't really mean to sell it; it was more of a joke. | |||
|judgment=Reversed. | |||
|reasons="The mental assent of the parties is not a requisite for the formation of a contract." | |||
|case_text_links={{Infobox Case Brief/Case Text Link | |||
|link=https://www.quimbee.com/cases/lucy-v-zehmer | |||
|case_text_source=Quimbee video summary | |||
}}{{Infobox Case Brief/Case Text Link | |||
|link=https://law.justia.com/cases/virginia/supreme-court/1954/4272-1.html | |||
|case_text_source=Justia | |||
}}{{Infobox Case Brief/Case Text Link | |||
|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pa6vEi3JgyY | |||
|case_text_source=YaleCourses | |||
}} | |||
}} | }} | ||
Revision as of 19:26, July 1, 2023
| Lucy v. Zehmer | |
| Court | Virginia Supreme Court |
|---|---|
| Citation | 196 Va. 493 (1954) |
| Date decided | November 22, 1954 |
Facts
Zehmer owned a large farm in Virginia that Lucy wanted to buy, and he had tried to buy for several years.
One night when Zehmer was drunk, Lucy and he were arguing about if Lucy could afford to buy the farm for $50,000. Lucy said, "I bet you wouldn't take $50,000 for that place." Zehmer responded, "Yes I would too; you wouldn't give fifty." An agreement was made and written up on the spot that the farm would be sold to Lucy for $50,000. Zehmer and his wife signed it along with Lucy.Issues
Is the agreement an enforceable contract, even if one party did not really mean to make an agreement?
Arguments
Zehmer said he was too drunk to make an agreement. He didn't really mean to sell it; it was more of a joke.
Judgment
Reversed.
Reasons
"The mental assent of the parties is not a requisite for the formation of a contract."
