Homami v. Iranzadi

From wikilawschool.net. Wiki Law School does not provide legal advice. For educational purposes only.
Revision as of 19:27, November 4, 2023 by DeRien (talk | contribs)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

Homami v. Iranzadi
Court California Court of Appeal
Citation Homami v. Iranzadi
Date decided June 26, 1989

Facts

  • Mr. Homami = "Homami" = plaintiff = lender
  • Mr. Iranzadi = "Iranzadi" = defendant = borrower
  • Homami & Iranzadi are brothers-in-law
  • Homami lent Iranzadi $250,000 to pay for a real estate transaction involving 2 properties.
  • The promissory notes stated that the loans didn't bear interest.
  • Iranzadi made payments of about $40,000/month.
  • Next, the 2 parties modified the promissory notes to accelerate the due date of the entire loans to the upcoming September.
  • The loans modification stipulated that after June 22, 1985, interest would be charged on the loans at a rate of 18%/year.
  • All of a suddenly, Iranzadi stopped making payments.

Procedural History

The 2 properties of Iranzadi went into foreclosure because Homami filed notices of default.

  • Iranzadi sold 1 property & paid back $125,000.
  • Iranzadi, however, didn't pay back the full $125,000 after selling the 2nd property.
  • Therefore, Homami didn't receive back the full $250,000 he had lent--let alone any interest.

Homami sued for breach of contract.

At trial, Homami told the court that the 2 parties had agreed to not report the interest payments in the modified contract to avoid paying taxes.

Homamai won in the California trial court.

Issues

Is a contract with an illegal purpose void?

Holding

Yes. A contract with an illegal purpose is contrary to public policy & void.

Judgment

Reversed

Reasons

3 judge panel: Courts refuse to enforce illegal agreements even if the non-enforcement benefits opposing parties because non-enforcement is a deterrent.

Rule

Courts won't help when

  1. un-licensed professionals or contractors sue customers for non-payments
  2. recovery of money is from illegal gambling
  3. contracts that break or avoid federal law

Resources