Wiki Law School will soon be moving! Please update your bookmarks. Our future address is www.wikilawschool.org |
Adams v. Lindsell: Difference between revisions
From wikilawschool.net. Wiki Law School does not provide legal advice. For educational purposes only.
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
Line 14: | Line 14: | ||
Lindsell received the Adams mailed reply on September 9th. Defendant (Lindsell) had already sold wool on September 8th. | Lindsell received the Adams mailed reply on September 9th. Defendant (Lindsell) had already sold wool on September 8th. | ||
|procedural_history=Adams (buyer of wool; plaintiff) sued Lindsell (seller of wool) for money damages. | |procedural_history=Adams (buyer of wool; plaintiff) sued Lindsell (seller of wool) for money damages. | ||
Adams (wool manufacturer & buyer) won in the trial court. | |||
|issues=Was Plaintiff's (Adams) purported acceptance actually an acceptance? | |issues=Was Plaintiff's (Adams) purported acceptance actually an acceptance? | ||
Is an offer accepted when the offeree (buyer Adams) places a letter of acceptance in the mail? | |||
|arguments=Defendant Lindsell (seller of wool) argued that no contract had been formed because he hadn't received the reply from Adams (buyer of wool; plaintiff). | |arguments=Defendant Lindsell (seller of wool) argued that no contract had been formed because he hadn't received the reply from Adams (buyer of wool; plaintiff). | ||
|holding=Yes, Plaintiff had accepted. | |holding=Yes, Plaintiff had accepted. | ||
An offer made via the postal system is properly accepted when the offeree places a letter accepting the offer in the mail. | |||
|reasons=There was a "meeting of the minds" as soon as Plaintiff posted his acceptance in the mail. | |reasons=There was a "meeting of the minds" as soon as Plaintiff posted his acceptance in the mail. | ||
Lord Ellenborough: The letter of acceptance needn't actually be received by the offeror (Lindsell). | |||
|rule=The [https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/mailbox_rule mailbox rule] states that acceptance takes effect as soon as a letter stating such is posted. | |rule=The [https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/mailbox_rule mailbox rule] states that acceptance takes effect as soon as a letter stating such is posted. | ||
|case_text_links={{Infobox Case Brief/Case Text Link | |case_text_links={{Infobox Case Brief/Case Text Link |
Revision as of 15:08, July 16, 2023
Adams v. Lindsell | |
Court | High Court of Justice, King's Bench Division |
---|---|
Citation | 106 Eng.Rep. 250 |
Date decided | 1818 |
Facts
Before 1800, parties signed a contract face-to-face. By the early 1800s, making & accepting offers by mail was becoming commonplace.
On September 2nd 1817, Mr. Lindsell mailed a letter to Mr. Adams who was a wool manufacturer.
Defendant (Lindsell) sent, by mail, an offer to sell wool. Due to Defendant's negligence, the offer was received late on September 5th 1817.
Plaintiff (Adams) immediately accepted on September 5th 1817 & replied via mail.
Lindsell received the Adams mailed reply on September 9th. Defendant (Lindsell) had already sold wool on September 8th.Procedural History
Adams (buyer of wool; plaintiff) sued Lindsell (seller of wool) for money damages.
Adams (wool manufacturer & buyer) won in the trial court.Issues
Was Plaintiff's (Adams) purported acceptance actually an acceptance?
Is an offer accepted when the offeree (buyer Adams) places a letter of acceptance in the mail?Arguments
Defendant Lindsell (seller of wool) argued that no contract had been formed because he hadn't received the reply from Adams (buyer of wool; plaintiff).
Holding
Yes, Plaintiff had accepted.
Reasons
There was a "meeting of the minds" as soon as Plaintiff posted his acceptance in the mail.
Lord Ellenborough: The letter of acceptance needn't actually be received by the offeror (Lindsell).Rule
The mailbox rule states that acceptance takes effect as soon as a letter stating such is posted.
Resources
Date | Action |
---|---|
September 2nd 1817 | Lindsell (seller of wool) mailed a offer letter to Adams (wool manufacturer & buyer). |
September 5th 1817 | Adams received the letter |
September 5th 1817 | Plaintiff (buyer Adams) immediately accepted to buy a large quantity of sheep wool on September 5th 1817 |
September 5th 1817 | Adams replied via mail |
September 7th 1817 | Lindsell (seller) hasn't heard from Adams (buyer) |
September 8th 1817 | Lindsell sold the wool to another buyer (not Adams) |
September 9th 1817 | Lindsell (seller) received the acceptance letter |