Citizens v. Ouhrabka: Difference between revisions

From wikilawschool.net. Wiki Law School does not provide legal advice. For educational purposes only.
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 10: Line 10:
*Ouhrabka's house with his wife was worth $1/4 million at the time
*Ouhrabka's house with his wife was worth $1/4 million at the time
*The jewelry store was placed into receivership.
*The jewelry store was placed into receivership.
|procedural_history=* Citizens Bank sued Ouhrabka in a Vermont state court seeking to recover an estimated $10 million.
|procedural_history=*Citizens Bank sued Ouhrabka in a Vermont state court seeking to recover an estimated $10 million.
*Citizens sought to attach a writ to Ouhrabka's house
*Citizens lost & was denied the writ because Ouhrabka's wife was not a debtor
*Citizens filed an interlocutory appeal to the Vermont Supreme Court
*
|issues=Can an individual creditor of 1 spouse satisfy a debt personally owned by that spouse by attaching a lien to property jointly held by both spouses (tenants by the entirety)?
|rule=* [https://www.quimbee.com/keyterms/tenancy-by-the-entirety tenancy by the entirety] = American co-ownership of land between spouses
|rule=* [https://www.quimbee.com/keyterms/tenancy-by-the-entirety tenancy by the entirety] = American co-ownership of land between spouses
|case_text_links={{Infobox Case Brief/Case Text Link
|case_text_links={{Infobox Case Brief/Case Text Link

Revision as of 21:51, April 26, 2024

Citizens v. Ouhrabka
Court Vermont Supreme Court
Citation 190 Vt. 251, 30 A.3d 1266
Date decided August 5, 2011

Facts

  • Ouhrabka was the owner of a jewelry store in Rhode Island
  • RBS Citizens, N.A. = Citizens Bank = a bank that loaned Ouhrabka's company more than $15 million
  • In August 2006, Ouhrabka signed a personal guarantee with Citizens Banks ("Citizens") whereby he became personally responsible for 1/2 million dollars of the debt
  • Later on, Ouhrabka accepted personal liability for all of the jewelry company's debt
  • Ouhrabka submitted a financial statement to Citizens listing his house that he co-owned with his wife as tenants by the entirety
  • Ouhrabka's house with his wife was worth $1/4 million at the time
  • The jewelry store was placed into receivership.

Procedural History

  • Citizens Bank sued Ouhrabka in a Vermont state court seeking to recover an estimated $10 million.
  • Citizens sought to attach a writ to Ouhrabka's house
  • Citizens lost & was denied the writ because Ouhrabka's wife was not a debtor
  • Citizens filed an interlocutory appeal to the Vermont Supreme Court

Issues

Can an individual creditor of 1 spouse satisfy a debt personally owned by that spouse by attaching a lien to property jointly held by both spouses (tenants by the entirety)?

Rule

Resources