Wiki Law School will soon be moving! Please update your bookmarks. Our future address is www.wikilawschool.org |
Pierson v. Post: Difference between revisions
From wikilawschool.net. Wiki Law School does not provide legal advice. For educational purposes only.
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
Line 4: | Line 4: | ||
|date=1805 | |date=1805 | ||
|subject=Property | |subject=Property | ||
|facts=* Mr. Post = an enthusiastic fox hunter | |facts=*Mr. Post = an enthusiastic fox hunter | ||
* Mr. Pierson = killer of the fox that Mr. Post was hunting | *Mr. Pierson = killer of the fox that Mr. Post was hunting | ||
* Post claimed ownership of the dead fox in | *Post claimed ownership of the dead fox in December 1802 in the state of New York | ||
* Pierson refused to hand over the dead fox | *Pierson refused to hand over the dead fox | ||
* | * | ||
|procedural_history=Post (regular fox hunter) sued Pierson for trespass. | |procedural_history=Post (regular fox hunter) sued Pierson for trespass. |
Revision as of 21:02, April 24, 2024
Pierson v. Post | |
Court | New York Court of Appeals |
---|---|
Citation | 3 Cai. R. 175 |
Date decided | 1805 |
Facts
- Mr. Post = an enthusiastic fox hunter
- Mr. Pierson = killer of the fox that Mr. Post was hunting
- Post claimed ownership of the dead fox in December 1802 in the state of New York
- Pierson refused to hand over the dead fox
Procedural History
Post (regular fox hunter) sued Pierson for trespass.
Post won in the trial court.Issues
- Can a person obtain property rights over a wild animal merely by chasing it during a hunt?
- Who owns a dead animal?
Holding
Judge Daniel Tompkins (the future VP of the United States): Pierson acquired ownership of the fox when he killed it.
Judgment
Reversed
Reasons
Rule
Pursuit alone is not enough to give the pursuer property rights
according to
- Daniel Tompkins
- Fleta (a British source of Common Law)
- Justinian (Eastern Roman ruler)
- Henry of Bracton (1210 - 1268)
- Grotius (1583 - 1645)
- Samuel von Pufendorf (1632 - 1694)
- William Blackstone (1723 - 1780)
Comments
Henry Livingston (future SCOTUS justice 1757 - 1823) dissented: Pursuit of a wild animal is sufficient to acquire possessory rights over it.
Resources