NIPSCO v. Carbon County: Difference between revisions

From wikilawschool.net. Wiki Law School does not provide legal advice. For educational purposes only.
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 11: Line 11:
*Coal prices went up:
*Coal prices went up:
*{{Timeline|1=$24/ton of coal|2=year 1978|3=$44/ton of coal|4=year 1985|5=|6=|7=|8=|9=|10=|11=|12=|13=|14=|15=|16=|17=|18=}}
*{{Timeline|1=$24/ton of coal|2=year 1978|3=$44/ton of coal|4=year 1985|5=|6=|7=|8=|9=|10=|11=|12=|13=|14=|15=|16=|17=|18=}}
*
 
*NIPSCO found a cheaper source of electricity; so, NIPSCO suspended the coal shipments from Carbon County.
*NIPSCO found a cheaper source of electricity; so, NIPSCO suspended the coal shipments from Carbon County.
*
 
|procedural_history=NIPSCO sued Carbon County in federal court in Indiana seeking a declaratory judgment that NIPSCO was excused from buying coal from Carbon County under ''force majeure''.
|procedural_history=NIPSCO sued Carbon County in federal court in Indiana seeking a declaratory judgment that NIPSCO was excused from buying coal from Carbon County under ''force majeure''.
|case_text_links={{Infobox Case Brief/Case Text Link
|case_text_links={{Infobox Case Brief/Case Text Link

Revision as of 18:05, December 13, 2023

NIPSCO v. Carbon County
Court 7th Circuit
Citation 799 F.2d 265
Date decided August 13, 1986

Facts

  • Northern Indiana Public Service Co. = "NIPSCO" = plaintiff = coal buyer = electric utility company
  • Carbon County Coal Co. (Carbon County) = coal mine company = company with a Wyoming coal mine on federal land = coal seller
  • In 1978, the 2 parties contracted for NIPSCO to receive 1,500,000 (1.5 million) tons of coal/year for 20 years.
  • The 2 parties agreed on $24/ton of coal subject to change.
  • The contract included a force majeure clause.
  • Coal prices went up:
year 1978
$24/ton of coal
$44/ton of coal
year 1985






  • NIPSCO found a cheaper source of electricity; so, NIPSCO suspended the coal shipments from Carbon County.

Procedural History

NIPSCO sued Carbon County in federal court in Indiana seeking a declaratory judgment that NIPSCO was excused from buying coal from Carbon County under force majeure.

Resources